Panasonic HDC-SD1
Panasonic HDC-SD1
1
Panasonic HDC-SD1
Editor's Review
The Panasonic HDC-SD1 camcorder is perhaps the most remarkable entry into the new class of high-definition camcorders, with advanced HD capabilities that will bring a cinematic level of detail to your home movies. For one, the SD1 is so-named because it records video directly to Secure Digital memory cards. Solid state flash memory. There are no moving parts involved in the recording process, which means there's less stuff that can get broken and ruin your camcorder or your recording. Top it all off with a really amazing zoom microphone that follows the lens and can capture excellent sound and great distances, and you've got a really wonderful camcorder.
Specifications
- 3CCD High Definition Camcorder
- Records directly to Secure Digital memory cards (4GB SD card included, good for up to 1 hour of video)
- 12x optical zoom
- Image stabilization
- 5.1-channel audio recording, zoom microphone
- Part Number: HDCSD1
- UPC: 037988255214
- Release Date: May 18, 2007
Shop for HDC-SD1 Accessories
Panasonic HDC-SD1 Comments & Questions (write your own!)
HELP (Nico — 11/18/2010)
would this be useful with final cut pro on a mac and would it be useful for a professional looking finish on a film <?
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (11/20/2010)
If you're looking for a professional looking finish, for that kind of money I'd look at the Canon T2i or 7D with a good lens. That way you have the ability to toy with the depth of field. DSLRs doing video is the trend in my mind.
reply to this comment
pauline (09/19/2010)
how do I finalise my dvd using the hdc sd1 camera and hd writer
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (09/20/2010)
You need to do it in camera. And your AC adapter is required. Look I. Your camera settings.
reply to this comment
IMovie '08 and Panasonic HDC SD1 (PPierce1 — 04/06/2008)
If I purchase iLife '08 (for iMovie '08) will I be able to see and download HD video from a Panasonic HDC SD1 or do I need a special driver for the camcorder for it to be seen on my intel-based iMac. I am ultimately hoping to be able to create HD DVDs of video shot using this camcorder with my mac. Any help will be appreciated.
reply to this comment
Aditya D (04/06/2008)
The Apple site confirms that the HDC SD1 will work just fine with iMovie.
Here is a full list of compatibilities:
support.apple.com/kb/HT1014... there is no special details, you shouldn't need any special drivers.
Hope this helps.
reply to this comment
Here is a full list of compatibilities:
support.apple.com/kb/HT1014... there is no special details, you shouldn't need any special drivers.
Hope this helps.
HD writer for HDC-SD3 panasonic camera (khanfaisal — 12/12/2007)
I owned HDC-SD3 panasonic camera purchased from Japan. The only problem i am facing is with the HD writer as it is in Japanese. Can any one help me on this. I think english version of HDC-SD5 would do. If any one have this please inform me.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (12/12/2007)
I'm not sure what you're asking here. Do you want to replace the Japanese firmware of your camera with English firmware? If so, I'd recommend talking to Panasonic about that. It's possible, though some functions and features may rendered inoperative as a result.
And you need to be dead on sure because if you're wrong, you can easily brick your camera/writer.
reply to this comment
And you need to be dead on sure because if you're wrong, you can easily brick your camera/writer.
khanfaisal (12/19/2007)
Dear James;
i would like to have an english version of the HD writer. the current verssion for HDC-SD3 is V1.5J but in japanese ofcourse. new model is panasonic SD5 using V2 i would like to know that if anyone have the english version of HD writer.
Even if englissh version of older model SD1 is available i think it will also help.
Or plz suggest any alternative or other software which can run AVHCD files .MTS
thanks
reply to this comment
i would like to have an english version of the HD writer. the current verssion for HDC-SD3 is V1.5J but in japanese ofcourse. new model is panasonic SD5 using V2 i would like to know that if anyone have the english version of HD writer.
Even if englissh version of older model SD1 is available i think it will also help.
Or plz suggest any alternative or other software which can run AVHCD files .MTS
thanks
by James DeRuvo (01/14/2008)
I assume you're talking about firmware. You're best bet would be to talk to Panasonic directly about this. Otherwise you run the risk of bricking your unit and voiding your warranty. But if there's a US equivalent, it's quite possible the english firmware will work.
reply to this comment
WILL TOAST8 HELP TO CONVERT VIDEO FROM PANASONIC HDC-SD1 TO NON INTEL IMAC G5? (VINCYMAN50 — 11/26/2007)
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (11/27/2007)
It will copy to the iPod, PSP, mobile phone, and more. And if your NonIntel Mac recognizes the camera, then Toast should work fine in that context. But you'd probably be better off converting using Quicktime Pro and let Toast burn your DVDs. And for $29.99, it's a utility every mac video user should have it.
reply to this comment
SDHC cards - Class 2 vs. Class 4 or Class 6 (runnertd — 09/10/2007)
The SDHC card that came with my Panasonic HDC-SD1camcorder is a 4GB Class 2 card. Can the camcorder also use SDHC cards that are Class 4 or Class 6? It seems that the higher class cards should be more expensive, but at Amazon, the higher class cards are like 1/3 the price of a Class 2 card.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (09/12/2007)
It should be that way, but maybe Amazon is trying to move customers towards the newer, faster cards since they have more in stock. I'm bettering that's the case.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (09/19/2007)
Hi, I noticed that you haven't marked any replies as the "best answer." Are you still looking for an answer? If so, I recommend you re-submit it on digitalcamera-hq.com so it will have a better chance of being noticed. These days it looks like most questions are being answered within a few days.
If you're happy with the answer you received, you can simply click on "Mark for best answer" bubble and it will close out the question. Thanks for posting it and Good luck!
reply to this comment
If you're happy with the answer you received, you can simply click on "Mark for best answer" bubble and it will close out the question. Thanks for posting it and Good luck!
Francis Catayong (10/05/2009)
Can I use SDHC Class 6 for my Nikon S series? I bought the camera with a Class 2 SDHC. Thanks.
reply to this comment
Panasonic HDC-SD1 or Canon HV-20 or ? (sjkblack1 — 09/07/2007)
Ah, the joys of finding the perfect fit...or not. I am looking to buy a new camcorder to do multiple jobs. 1) Work with my Workprinter XP converting Reg/Super 8MM film to digital 2) Use for general home movies 3) use for filming family documentary. The problem is that the equipment/software I have seems to have different needs.
Have:
Mac PowerPC G5 w/ 1.8 ghz and 512 mb SDRAM and OS X 10.4.10 (about 4ish years old)
Final Cut Express HD
iMovie 6 (can get 8 if needed)
Camcorder need:
12x Optical zoom (Workprinter preferred minimum)
3 CCD (preferred)
High Def (might as well get the best technology)
Standard Def setting (Workprinter only works with SD now...company working solution)
Tape or SD card storage
So, I am having trouble find a one-size fits all needs solution. If I get a High Def camera, does the 3 CCD add much? Any suggestions/held would be greatly appreciated.
S. Black
reply to this comment
Have:
Mac PowerPC G5 w/ 1.8 ghz and 512 mb SDRAM and OS X 10.4.10 (about 4ish years old)
Final Cut Express HD
iMovie 6 (can get 8 if needed)
Camcorder need:
12x Optical zoom (Workprinter preferred minimum)
3 CCD (preferred)
High Def (might as well get the best technology)
Standard Def setting (Workprinter only works with SD now...company working solution)
Tape or SD card storage
So, I am having trouble find a one-size fits all needs solution. If I get a High Def camera, does the 3 CCD add much? Any suggestions/held would be greatly appreciated.
S. Black
by James DeRuvo (09/08/2007)
Well, depending on who you talk to, the SD1 either is or is not compatible with your MAC. Whereas, the Canon will be without a doubt. I'm pointing to the Canon. The advantage of a 3CCD isn't what it once was. Single chips have improved so much that the different is negligible.
Go Canon. in the long run, it's going to work out better for you as a mac user.
reply to this comment
Go Canon. in the long run, it's going to work out better for you as a mac user.
Which HD camcorders are compatible with Apple computers, i.e. dual core OS10.4 and iLife 08? (drmarving — 08/15/2007)
I'm looking for a HD camcprder replacement for my Panasonic PV-DV 953 which is great but too heavy and not HD. We have several Apple computers, dual core desk top iMac and G4 PowerBook (About to be replaced by iBook Pro).
Any suggestions appreciated.
I'd like image stabilization, at least 10x optical and hopefully a viewfinder.
reply to this comment
Any suggestions appreciated.
I'd like image stabilization, at least 10x optical and hopefully a viewfinder.
by James DeRuvo (08/17/2007)
Well the good news is that with iLife08, Apple now offers native AVCHD support. So you should be able to use just about any firewire capable camcorder that encodes in that format. I like Canon since they seem to be designed with mac compatibility in mind, but if it has a firewire port, it'll work in Mac. You may, however, run into trouble with Sony and Panasonic. Check before you buy.
One thing about iMovie 08 you may not be aware of. It's been completely rewritten from the ground up and frankly, it's been Dumbed down. Gone are great features like titling and some great effects. However, the render engine is near instantaneous. So there are tradeoffs for the ease of use. The good news is that Apple is aware of this and offers iMovie06 as a free download for new iLife 08 users.
reply to this comment
One thing about iMovie 08 you may not be aware of. It's been completely rewritten from the ground up and frankly, it's been Dumbed down. Gone are great features like titling and some great effects. However, the render engine is near instantaneous. So there are tradeoffs for the ease of use. The good news is that Apple is aware of this and offers iMovie06 as a free download for new iLife 08 users.
drmarving (08/17/2007)
Thanks for the info. I'll probably go the Canon route.
MG
reply to this comment
MG
by James DeRuvo (08/30/2007)
Cool. BTW - I noticed that you haven't marked any replies as the "best answer." Totally fine if you want to keep the question open for a little while to see what others have to say. But if you're satisfied, marking best answer will close out the question from active status.
reply to this comment
f252863 (09/14/2007)
Apple does NOT go native avchd, they change it to another format which is 6-10 times larger making file sizes way too big. Get Ulead Visual Studio 11 it does proxy editing, much better.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (09/15/2007)
Uh, Charles, iMovie 08 ( apple.com/ilife/imovie/ ) has AVCHD support:
Expanded format support - iMovie supports standard and high definition video, as well as the most popular formats, including DV, HDV, MPEG-2, MPEG-4 and even AVCHD. However, it requires an Intel-based Mac.
And in Final Cut Pro ( apple.com/finalcutstudio/sp... ), AVCHD[ support is available with a Mac Pro with an Intel Xeon processor.
The compatibility list is here ( docs.info.apple.com/article... ).
reply to this comment
Expanded format support - iMovie supports standard and high definition video, as well as the most popular formats, including DV, HDV, MPEG-2, MPEG-4 and even AVCHD. However, it requires an Intel-based Mac.
And in Final Cut Pro ( apple.com/finalcutstudio/sp... ), AVCHD[ support is available with a Mac Pro with an Intel Xeon processor.
The compatibility list is here ( docs.info.apple.com/article... ).
in the future, will Quicktime pro or Final Cut Express support ACVHD? (cuvtixo — 07/12/2007)
Although Macintosh doesn't work with Panasonic HDC-SD1 or many Sony products, I suspect this may change in the future, especially if Final Cut Pro now supports ACVHD. Is there reason to think other Apple software won't follow?
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (07/12/2007)
That's a tough one. I think that more likely they might sell a plug in for it - much like you have to buy the MPEG2 plugin separately back in the day (due to royalties to the copyright holder of mpeg2).
You have to remember that Final Cut is a prosumer to professional editor. Whereas quicktime pro is merely a software encoder and playback device. And at $29.99 for QTP, I think it unlikely that ACVHD will get in there without an additional cost.
But there's a chance it'll eventually get integrated into iMovie, though.
IMHO, of course.
reply to this comment
You have to remember that Final Cut is a prosumer to professional editor. Whereas quicktime pro is merely a software encoder and playback device. And at $29.99 for QTP, I think it unlikely that ACVHD will get in there without an additional cost.
But there's a chance it'll eventually get integrated into iMovie, though.
IMHO, of course.
Which HD camcorder is going to be compatible with Adobe Premiere Elements? (richhensley01 — 07/10/2007)
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (07/12/2007)
Rich.
Well, once the video footage is downloaded to your computer, then it does not matter which HD camcorder it came from. The HD cams record in either an MPEG-2-4 format or in an MT2 file format, which means the video file has to be converted before importing it in any editing software for editing. The cams you will need to stay away from with Adobe Premiere is AVCHD files. JVC has a line of cams that record with AVCHD files.
reply to this comment
Well, once the video footage is downloaded to your computer, then it does not matter which HD camcorder it came from. The HD cams record in either an MPEG-2-4 format or in an MT2 file format, which means the video file has to be converted before importing it in any editing software for editing. The cams you will need to stay away from with Adobe Premiere is AVCHD files. JVC has a line of cams that record with AVCHD files.
How to buy? (bslee74 — 07/04/2007)
It is sold at $695 in online store, much cheaper than off-line store. Is it ok to buy online?
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (07/05/2007)
Sloth.
Camcorder Shopping Tips:
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor... Guides
7 Camcorder Pitfalls:>
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor... Camcorder Formats
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor...
reply to this comment
Camcorder Shopping Tips:
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor... Guides
7 Camcorder Pitfalls:>
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor... Camcorder Formats
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor...
Shari (07/05/2007)
Several reliable sites rate online stores that sell camcorders, so before you buy, check the store rating at this site, or CNET.com. Amazon, of course, has a great reputation for reliability and easy return policy.
For extra safety, use a credit card with a good online protection policy (Discover card is excellent, and you can down load a small program from them that will instantly give you a new card number for every online purchase--the card number is only good for that one purchase, so even a shady online store cannot reuse your card number.)
Also, you can register with Paypal, and use them to pay at various online stores--they pay the store without giving your credit card number, so Paypal is also a very safe way to shop. They do charge a fee to the seller though, so not all online stores except Paypal.
Even Ebay can be safe if you pay with paypal, read the seller's small print, and check the sellers feedback rating before buying. Make sure the seller has a lot of feedback (several hundred or more) and make sure the rating is in the high 90s, then read the negative feedback to make sure it is legitimate, then make your decision.
One last thing--always factor in shipping in your total end price, some stores (especially on ebay) charge unreasonably high shipping that brings the total price way up.
Good luck and Happy Shopping!
Shari
.
reply to this comment
For extra safety, use a credit card with a good online protection policy (Discover card is excellent, and you can down load a small program from them that will instantly give you a new card number for every online purchase--the card number is only good for that one purchase, so even a shady online store cannot reuse your card number.)
Also, you can register with Paypal, and use them to pay at various online stores--they pay the store without giving your credit card number, so Paypal is also a very safe way to shop. They do charge a fee to the seller though, so not all online stores except Paypal.
Even Ebay can be safe if you pay with paypal, read the seller's small print, and check the sellers feedback rating before buying. Make sure the seller has a lot of feedback (several hundred or more) and make sure the rating is in the high 90s, then read the negative feedback to make sure it is legitimate, then make your decision.
One last thing--always factor in shipping in your total end price, some stores (especially on ebay) charge unreasonably high shipping that brings the total price way up.
Good luck and Happy Shopping!
Shari
.
bslee74 (07/05/2007)
Thanks a lot guys, really helpful advices.
reply to this comment
Any problems with iMac OS 10.4.10? (jldasse94 — 06/30/2007)
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (07/02/2007)
Some Panasonics aren't compatible with MAC. The SD1 happens to be one of them. This is because it doesn't support firewire and also records in the proprietary ACVHD format. As far as I know, the only editor which has native support for this format is Final Cut Pro ($1300) - but from what I've read - only by transcoding.
But then you run into that USB problem.
reply to this comment
But then you run into that USB problem.
cuvtixo (07/12/2007)
AVCHD is proprietary, but a result of cooperation between Panasonic and Sony, not a single company. If Final Cut Pro works now, its quite possible that Final Cut Express and iMovie and maybe even Quicktime Pro may support this format sometime in the future. Perhaps an Apple insider might have a better idea as to when and how.
I have not had any problems with USB2 on Macs so I'm not sure what trouble anyone would have, other than it being slower/less convenient than Firewire(firewire works better with constant data streams, usb2 outpaces it with short bursts of speed.)
Anyone tried this OSX converter? mac1080hd.com/
reply to this comment
I have not had any problems with USB2 on Macs so I'm not sure what trouble anyone would have, other than it being slower/less convenient than Firewire(firewire works better with constant data streams, usb2 outpaces it with short bursts of speed.)
Anyone tried this OSX converter? mac1080hd.com/
by James DeRuvo (07/12/2007)
But here's where that theory begins to fall apart. Sony's notorious incompatibility elements - not the complete abandonment of Firewire in favor of USB2.0, which Panasonic seems to have followed.
So, at this point, I'd say your theory is speculative at best. Then again, so is mine. ;)
reply to this comment
So, at this point, I'd say your theory is speculative at best. Then again, so is mine. ;)
kf4wm (08/08/2007)
As of Tuesday Aug 7 Imovie 8 was announced by Apple and AVCHD is supported.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (08/08/2007)
I saw that. That's a great addition. It'll also import mpeg2, hdv and a host of other formats. And the interface looks incredible. I can't wait to play with it.
reply to this comment
Mushi (10/21/2007)
This camera does not show up in iMovie 7.1 (iLife 08) on my brand new MacBook Pro 2.2 LED. It works OK(ish) on all the other Macs I've tried it on. Has anybody had this camera working on one of the new Santa Rosa based MacBook Pros? Please let me know if you have, so I can discount a Santa Rosa mother-board incompatibility from my investigations.
reply to this comment
by James DeRuvo (10/22/2007)
Yeah, that is often what heppens when you get an update. Mostly due to the OS, but perhaps it's also the new version of iMovie. Sometimes connectivity gets broken. The good news is that Apple has iMovie 06 still available for 08 users who have problems with the new version. You can download it here. ( apple.com/support/downloads... )
reply to this comment
Can I create standard format DVD's with the Panasonic HDC-SD1? (hartlenb — 06/28/2007)
My old digital camera just died after my son dropped. Would like to get HD camera as that's all we watch but need to be able to create std DVD's for the grandparents. Nothing fancy, we just use Pinnacle and Roxio software. Need to know if I can get the video off the camera or card in a format that is recognizable by these programs.
Thanks in advance, Bryan
reply to this comment
Thanks in advance, Bryan
Shari (06/29/2007)
Using a computer you can convert HD video into DVD. Of course using a mini DVD camcorder would save you that step of using the computer.
Roxie Easy Media Creator 9 supports HD-v input and output. Below I have copied all the supported formats for Roxie.
Pinnacle offers "Pinnacle HD DVD Authoring Pack: Showcase Home Movies in Vivid HD"
Pinnacle Studio 11 supports HDV input and output.
One important thing to keep in mind is that some DVD players, especially the older ones, will not play all DVD formats, even DVDs that have been finalized.
It may be a good idea to see what kind of DVD player the grandparents use, for instance, if it is new, the manual may say "plays Dvd Video Dvd-r/-rw" then there should be no problem.
If they have an older dvd player, you might just want to upgrade them since the cost of multi DVD format DVD players has dropped.
Supported Input Formats for Roxie Easy Media Creator 9:
Video: AVI, DV, HD-V, DV-AVI, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, IFO/VOB, DivX, DivX HD, XviD, DVR-MS, TiVo, ASF, MOV, WMV, QuickTime, 3GP, MPEG2 Transport Stream, H.264, OpenDVD
Audio: Audio CD, MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby Digital AC-3, AAC, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, M4A, MP4, Playlists (WPL, ASX, M3U, PLS, XSPF)
Image: JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF
Supported Output Formats:
Video: AVI, DV-AVI, HD-V, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, DivX, DivX HD, WMV, WMV HD, H.264, MP4, 3GP
Audio: MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby Digital AC-3, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, MPEG-1/2, M4A, AAC, Playlists (M3U, PLS, XSPF, WPL, HighMAT, MPV)
Image: JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF
Video disc formats: DVD, Video CD (VCD), Super Video CD (SVCD), Mini DVD, BDAV
Recordable Formats:
Supports all popular recordable formats: CD-R/RW, DVD+R/RW, DVD-R/RW, DVD-R DL, DVD+R DL, DVD-RAM, BD-R/RE, BD-R/RE DL
Supports popular image formats: ISO, C2D, and BIN/CUE
reply to this comment
Roxie Easy Media Creator 9 supports HD-v input and output. Below I have copied all the supported formats for Roxie.
Pinnacle offers "Pinnacle HD DVD Authoring Pack: Showcase Home Movies in Vivid HD"
Pinnacle Studio 11 supports HDV input and output.
One important thing to keep in mind is that some DVD players, especially the older ones, will not play all DVD formats, even DVDs that have been finalized.
It may be a good idea to see what kind of DVD player the grandparents use, for instance, if it is new, the manual may say "plays Dvd Video Dvd-r/-rw" then there should be no problem.
If they have an older dvd player, you might just want to upgrade them since the cost of multi DVD format DVD players has dropped.
Supported Input Formats for Roxie Easy Media Creator 9:
Video: AVI, DV, HD-V, DV-AVI, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, IFO/VOB, DivX, DivX HD, XviD, DVR-MS, TiVo, ASF, MOV, WMV, QuickTime, 3GP, MPEG2 Transport Stream, H.264, OpenDVD
Audio: Audio CD, MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby Digital AC-3, AAC, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, M4A, MP4, Playlists (WPL, ASX, M3U, PLS, XSPF)
Image: JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF
Supported Output Formats:
Video: AVI, DV-AVI, HD-V, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, DivX, DivX HD, WMV, WMV HD, H.264, MP4, 3GP
Audio: MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby Digital AC-3, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, MPEG-1/2, M4A, AAC, Playlists (M3U, PLS, XSPF, WPL, HighMAT, MPV)
Image: JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF
Video disc formats: DVD, Video CD (VCD), Super Video CD (SVCD), Mini DVD, BDAV
Recordable Formats:
Supports all popular recordable formats: CD-R/RW, DVD+R/RW, DVD-R/RW, DVD-R DL, DVD+R DL, DVD-RAM, BD-R/RE, BD-R/RE DL
Supports popular image formats: ISO, C2D, and BIN/CUE
Mehtasaaab (01/04/2008)
Hi,
I recently I have purchashed Panasonic HD dvd camcorder. How can I convert HD dvd into std dvd. So my relatives can play dvd on their old tv and computer? Please send me step by step intructions.
Thanks in advance.
reply to this comment
I recently I have purchashed Panasonic HD dvd camcorder. How can I convert HD dvd into std dvd. So my relatives can play dvd on their old tv and computer? Please send me step by step intructions.
Thanks in advance.
Does the hdc-sd1 support 8GB SDHC's? (dmouse9499 — 06/24/2007)
reply to this comment
Greg (06/26/2007)
YES!! I bought A-DATA 8GB Secure Digital High-Capacity (SDHC) Class 2 on newegg.com ($65.99) and works perfectly.
reply to this comment
dmouse9499 (06/26/2007)
Awesome! Thanks!
reply to this comment
jmk (06/27/2007)
Yes, I too have an 8gb SDHC card and works great. Literature says its capable of up to 32 gb cards when they become available.
reply to this comment
Peng (07/31/2007)
Could you please tell an important thing:
How many minutes of real HD can be hold in your 8 GB SD card?
reply to this comment
How many minutes of real HD can be hold in your 8 GB SD card?
is the panasonic hdc-sd1 compatible with final cut pro express hd used on an emac? (louisenevelson — 06/06/2007)
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
The Panasonic hdc-sd1 records in ACVHD format which is still fairly new, so there is not much editing software available for this format yet, including Final Cut Express. Final Cut Studio at $1300 does support ACVHD video format. However, the bigger problem is, the Panasonic hdc-sd1 does not support a firewire connection to download your video footage to a Mac computer.
On the high-end consumer camcorders, the Canon HV20 will work nicely with Mac software such as: iMovie, iDVD, Garage Band, and Final Cut Express/Pro software Suite. If you plan to upgrade to a powerful Mac system, the HV20 is a nice choice. Lower budget camcorders with firewire connections will will also work like a charm with these software programs.
If you are planning to use your eMac for video downloading, video editing, making DVDs, and etc. I would recommend the following camcorders to work the best and efficient with within your system:
-Canon ZR700
-Canon ZR850
-Panasonic GS85
-Panasonic GS320
Each of these camcorders record video on miniDV tape without an MPEG file format which is the preferred choice by professionals for best all around performace. The GS320 camcorder offers 3-CCD image sensors for high quality video in the mid-range level. I would say that the GS320 is the highest resolution video you should use for your eMac. The ZR700 is a Little lower video resolution than the GS320, but the ZR700 offers more for your money, with external mic option, Analog to digital pass through, and more manual controls for the demanding entry level videographers,
Happy Shopping!
reply to this comment
On the high-end consumer camcorders, the Canon HV20 will work nicely with Mac software such as: iMovie, iDVD, Garage Band, and Final Cut Express/Pro software Suite. If you plan to upgrade to a powerful Mac system, the HV20 is a nice choice. Lower budget camcorders with firewire connections will will also work like a charm with these software programs.
If you are planning to use your eMac for video downloading, video editing, making DVDs, and etc. I would recommend the following camcorders to work the best and efficient with within your system:
-Canon ZR700
-Canon ZR850
-Panasonic GS85
-Panasonic GS320
Each of these camcorders record video on miniDV tape without an MPEG file format which is the preferred choice by professionals for best all around performace. The GS320 camcorder offers 3-CCD image sensors for high quality video in the mid-range level. I would say that the GS320 is the highest resolution video you should use for your eMac. The ZR700 is a Little lower video resolution than the GS320, but the ZR700 offers more for your money, with external mic option, Analog to digital pass through, and more manual controls for the demanding entry level videographers,
Happy Shopping!
louisenevelson (06/06/2007)
this was an extremely informative response, thank you so much. also somewhat prescient. i am looking for an external mic input. i was lookin at the canon optura Xi--any thoughts on these? or the pricier Xl1? i am a video neophyte but long time 16mm filmmaker so educated and so uneducated (and picky and poor) all at the same time
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
The Canon optura Xi records in an MPEG-4 format, MPEG video files are not very desirable for serious videographers. MPEG video files are compressed files and have to be uncompressed by converting it to a video format for editing on your Mac. It can be done but its more of a hassle, then when you burn a DVD it will compress again, losing more quality.
The ZR 700 offers an external mic option and records video without an MPEG format.
reply to this comment
The ZR 700 offers an external mic option and records video without an MPEG format.
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
Louise.
I would recommend higher quality options for you if you had a much more powerful Mac, either way the camcorders I have listed are digital and will produce a cleaner picture than most analog video camcorders you have probably seen in the past.
If can do without the mic option, the GS320 is great choice which also records without an MPEG format.
Happy Shopping!
reply to this comment
I would recommend higher quality options for you if you had a much more powerful Mac, either way the camcorders I have listed are digital and will produce a cleaner picture than most analog video camcorders you have probably seen in the past.
If can do without the mic option, the GS320 is great choice which also records without an MPEG format.
Happy Shopping!
louisenevelson (06/06/2007)
the canon zr700 does not have an external mic jack
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
Yes, the Canon ZR700 most certainly has an external mic option. I know this for a fact, as I know others that use the ZR700 with an external mic.
Some ZR models don't.
reply to this comment
Some ZR models don't.
louisenevelson (06/06/2007)
also on the canon optura Xi the user can record in tape mode or onto the memory card.
reply to this comment
louisenevelson (06/06/2007)
Audio
This model captures audio with a stereo microphone that is located underneath the video light. In the menu system, the user has the option to record audio in 12 bit and 16 bits. The camcorder does not have a microphone jack, which handicaps the use of an external microphone. It is puzzling that Canon has put a microphone-in port on the low-end ZR500, yet omit it from the upper-tier models. They explained that educators are one of the large markets for low-end ZR camcorders. This group also demanded mic inputs. Canon conceded, but why hold out on the other models? Surely it can’t cost more than few cents. Thus is the mystery of pricing
reply to this comment
This model captures audio with a stereo microphone that is located underneath the video light. In the menu system, the user has the option to record audio in 12 bit and 16 bits. The camcorder does not have a microphone jack, which handicaps the use of an external microphone. It is puzzling that Canon has put a microphone-in port on the low-end ZR500, yet omit it from the upper-tier models. They explained that educators are one of the large markets for low-end ZR camcorders. This group also demanded mic inputs. Canon conceded, but why hold out on the other models? Surely it can’t cost more than few cents. Thus is the mystery of pricing
louisenevelson (06/06/2007)
ok, piero--perhaps tired of this--have found, finally a space that says the zr 700 does support an external mic. so scary that all the reviews and product stats say it doesn't--it is so confusing--stores have such little stock, hard to look and hold and know. anyway--any other reccommendations for a mini dv that has an external mic, 3ccds or the 2.2 ccd, (or comparable) and is compatible with an emac running final cut express hd would be greatly appreciated--i am still researching the first suggestions as there is such contradictory info on the web. thank you.
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
Louise.
I have recommended the best choice for your system, but if you want the Optura Xi, then buy it. The Xi produces a very nice picture quality over the ZR700, but the Xi will not operate as efficient for downloading your video on your eMac.
Keep-in mind that video recorded on a secondary media such as an SD memory card, does not record in high quality video. They are usually recorded in MJPEG formats or similar, its OK for small QuickTime movies, emailing quality, and web work.
Bottom Line: If you are going to start comparing all the functions and features, then I first recommend to upgrade your Mac, then we choose the best cam for your video needs. In the meantime, an inexpensive camcorder like the ZR700 would be a good starting choice for your eMac. A 60 minute video from the ZR700 will take up around 9GB-10GB of hard drive space, so there is allot of info to work with. If you get a higher resolution camcorder, you will need allot more Processing and Ram memory power.
reply to this comment
I have recommended the best choice for your system, but if you want the Optura Xi, then buy it. The Xi produces a very nice picture quality over the ZR700, but the Xi will not operate as efficient for downloading your video on your eMac.
Keep-in mind that video recorded on a secondary media such as an SD memory card, does not record in high quality video. They are usually recorded in MJPEG formats or similar, its OK for small QuickTime movies, emailing quality, and web work.
Bottom Line: If you are going to start comparing all the functions and features, then I first recommend to upgrade your Mac, then we choose the best cam for your video needs. In the meantime, an inexpensive camcorder like the ZR700 would be a good starting choice for your eMac. A 60 minute video from the ZR700 will take up around 9GB-10GB of hard drive space, so there is allot of info to work with. If you get a higher resolution camcorder, you will need allot more Processing and Ram memory power.
Barker Reynolds (06/06/2007)
I've appreciated the input here.
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/06/2007)
Thanks, Barker.
If you have any questions in reference to the SD1, you can post them at the top of this page or any general questions at this link:
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor...
reply to this comment
If you have any questions in reference to the SD1, you can post them at the top of this page or any general questions at this link:
digitalcamera-hq.com/camcor...
Carlos (06/07/2007)
Piero Foto said - Final Cut Studio at $1300 does support ACVHD video format. -
I don't believe this statement is correct.
[edited for spelling]
reply to this comment
I don't believe this statement is correct.
[edited for spelling]
Piero Foto (06/07/2007)
I don't know for sure since I haven't use Final Cut Studio, but I can only go with what is published. I use Final Cut Express, which I know that does not support ACVHD.
If you know for sure, then re-confirm your statement.
videomaker.com/grid/hd-edit...
reply to this comment
If you know for sure, then re-confirm your statement.
videomaker.com/grid/hd-edit...
Carlos (06/28/2007)
reply to this comment
are there any media card readers that can place AVCHD on an HDTV? (Enzo — 05/31/2007)
I'm lazy, don't like to plug a camcorder into my TV everytime I want to view a video. I'd like to find a media reader to use with this camcorder (or any using card storage) that would allow me to place the SDHC card, mem stick, etc in it and, via an HDMI or equivalent cable, place the video on my TV with out quality loss.
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (05/31/2007)
Hey, Brian.
Not yet, AVCHD is still fairly new, but I am sure they will have some type of reader or solution for this in the very near future.
The Panasonic HDC-SD1 is the first camcorder we've seen to use the new AVCHD (Advanced Video Codec High Definition) format. This is based around the newer and more efficient MPEG-4 AVC codec (or h.264 as it's also known), which is also used on some HD-DVD and Blu-ray movies. This means that the resulting video takes up less space, and it's this feature that allows the HDC-SD1 to substitute traditional magnetic tapes for a tiny memory card.
AVCHD video uses roughly half the space of HDV video 13Mbit/s compared to 25Mbit/s. Despite this considerable improvement, you can still only fit around 20 minutes of footage on a 2GB SD card. Because of this limitation, Panasonic has opted to support the new SDHC card standard and has included a 4GB SDHC card that'll hold a more respectable 40 minutes of video.
The only problem with SDHC cards is that they aren't compatible with standard SD card readers. You'll either need a new card reader or you'll have to use the USB cable each time you wish to connect the camcorder to a PC.
Some basic software is provided for transferring clips to your PC, doing some basic editing and then archiving the results to DVD. There are currently no full editing packages with support for AVCHD video, but popular applications like Sony Vegas and Adobe Premiere should implement support soon.
Check out this link, there might be some good info that could be usefull to you for the SD1.
dvinfo.net/conf/showthread....
reply to this comment
Not yet, AVCHD is still fairly new, but I am sure they will have some type of reader or solution for this in the very near future.
The Panasonic HDC-SD1 is the first camcorder we've seen to use the new AVCHD (Advanced Video Codec High Definition) format. This is based around the newer and more efficient MPEG-4 AVC codec (or h.264 as it's also known), which is also used on some HD-DVD and Blu-ray movies. This means that the resulting video takes up less space, and it's this feature that allows the HDC-SD1 to substitute traditional magnetic tapes for a tiny memory card.
AVCHD video uses roughly half the space of HDV video 13Mbit/s compared to 25Mbit/s. Despite this considerable improvement, you can still only fit around 20 minutes of footage on a 2GB SD card. Because of this limitation, Panasonic has opted to support the new SDHC card standard and has included a 4GB SDHC card that'll hold a more respectable 40 minutes of video.
The only problem with SDHC cards is that they aren't compatible with standard SD card readers. You'll either need a new card reader or you'll have to use the USB cable each time you wish to connect the camcorder to a PC.
Some basic software is provided for transferring clips to your PC, doing some basic editing and then archiving the results to DVD. There are currently no full editing packages with support for AVCHD video, but popular applications like Sony Vegas and Adobe Premiere should implement support soon.
Check out this link, there might be some good info that could be usefull to you for the SD1.
dvinfo.net/conf/showthread....
Enzo (06/01/2007)
Thanks for the help. Since Sony is supposed to be coming out in July with the HDR-CX7 that uses the DuoPro memory stick for the same AVCHD format, I hope you're right about the viewers and software being soon to follow.
reply to this comment
Piero Foto (06/02/2007)
Brian.
Before buying any camcorder with AVCHD, its best that you first consider all the other issues of transferring/downloading video, editing, burning DVDs, and etc.
AVCHD files looks like it could be the choice over MPEG files, but it still early to tell what readers and advanced software will be available for AVCHD. I would say for that as AVCHD gets popular, there will be allot more conversion/editing software available for that format, but as far as the possabilities of AVCHD reader/players go, the chances would be more likely in the professional market. I know that does not do you any good for your needs.
Bottom Line:
At the present time, miniDV is still the best video format. All compressed video files from hard drive and DVD disc players create extra steps and hassles when it comes to doing anything else but straight viewing from your original source to TV. There are many people like yourself also hoping for an AVCHD reader/player to TV, but truthfully, when there is finally going to be one, its going to cost more than the camcorder itself. Your best bet is using a camcorder to playback AVCHD video to your TV, even if you have to buy a cheaper 2nd AVCHD cam just to leave hooked up to your TV at all times as a player.
Happy shopping!
reply to this comment
Before buying any camcorder with AVCHD, its best that you first consider all the other issues of transferring/downloading video, editing, burning DVDs, and etc.
AVCHD files looks like it could be the choice over MPEG files, but it still early to tell what readers and advanced software will be available for AVCHD. I would say for that as AVCHD gets popular, there will be allot more conversion/editing software available for that format, but as far as the possabilities of AVCHD reader/players go, the chances would be more likely in the professional market. I know that does not do you any good for your needs.
Bottom Line:
At the present time, miniDV is still the best video format. All compressed video files from hard drive and DVD disc players create extra steps and hassles when it comes to doing anything else but straight viewing from your original source to TV. There are many people like yourself also hoping for an AVCHD reader/player to TV, but truthfully, when there is finally going to be one, its going to cost more than the camcorder itself. Your best bet is using a camcorder to playback AVCHD video to your TV, even if you have to buy a cheaper 2nd AVCHD cam just to leave hooked up to your TV at all times as a player.
Happy shopping!
Kevin Altis (09/02/2007)
AVCHD and the PS3
The PS3 can play back raw AVCHD (.m2ts) files from AVCHD camcorders as well as .m2t files you get from an HDV camcorder like the Canon HV20. You can play these files from the PS3 internal hard disk, an external USB 2.0 hard disk attached to the PS3 or any of the built-in memory card readers such as SDHC, which is what you would be using if you have an AVCHD camcorder. You'll want to upgrade to firmware release 1.90 or later for the best results.
HDV issues
Since many people are still waiting for the quality to improve on AVCHD (currently too compressed), here's the related info for HDV. For raw .m2t files (HDV), many people like to burn DVDs of the footage taken from their cameras and play them back on the PS3 to avoid any footage changes or recompression that would be caused by conversion to another format. See the August 15th post in the following thread for details on burning discs and playing them back on the PS3.
hv20.com/showthread.php?t=263
reply to this comment
The PS3 can play back raw AVCHD (.m2ts) files from AVCHD camcorders as well as .m2t files you get from an HDV camcorder like the Canon HV20. You can play these files from the PS3 internal hard disk, an external USB 2.0 hard disk attached to the PS3 or any of the built-in memory card readers such as SDHC, which is what you would be using if you have an AVCHD camcorder. You'll want to upgrade to firmware release 1.90 or later for the best results.
HDV issues
Since many people are still waiting for the quality to improve on AVCHD (currently too compressed), here's the related info for HDV. For raw .m2t files (HDV), many people like to burn DVDs of the footage taken from their cameras and play them back on the PS3 to avoid any footage changes or recompression that would be caused by conversion to another format. See the August 15th post in the following thread for details on burning discs and playing them back on the PS3.
hv20.com/showthread.php?t=263
Joaquin (09/16/2007)
Yes,the upgraded to v.1.90 or later PLAYSTATION 3 can play AVCHD video and 5.1 sound SDHC cards recorded with the PANASONIC SD1. Adjust the PS3 to 1080p full HD, then connet it to a HD TV panel trough their HDMI connectors and you'll get a a better image than the outputed by the HDMI camera itsef. Slip the SDHC card into de PS3 card reader slot and be prepared to see the incredible sharpness, natural color and the best ressolution that comes out from it . This has been my own experience.
reply to this comment
Panasonic HDC-SD1 Reviews
Panasonic HDC-SD1 Reviews by Camcorder HQ Users
- 3.0 out of 5
bad for bright light
(josph thomas — 09/05/2007)
Excellent result in low light-no or very blurred picture at bright light especially beach, snow or during noon time-I tried all combinations of manual setting to see if we can improve-no way. The sensor is made only for low light shooting. I had to return, as I shoot lot of bright scenes. If you dont this is the camra. If adequate light, this is the best camera.
But dont think others make better camera- think still this is the winner. I tried sony, canon, JVC. Canonis the worst sone in between. Please dont trust any reviews-they all are biased.
